Skip to main content

Rustic Pizza | Our Story

The Neighborhood Italian Everyone Claims

Since our original location on Lincoln Avenue opened in 2020, Rustic Pizza & Pasteria has been serving Staten Island a fresh take on Italian comfort food, combining the warmth of a neighborhood pizzeria with the experience of a full-service Italian restaurant. From handcrafted specialty pizzas and house-made pasta to classic Italian entrées and creative seasonal dishes, Rustic focuses on great food in a casual, welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're joining us for a family dinner, happy hour, takeout, catering, or a special celebration, our goal is simple: Award-Winning. Neighborhood Favorite. Always Rustic.
The Award Winning Team Of Partners

The Award Winning Team Of Partners

• Founding and managing partners include Peter Botros, Executive Chef and Creative Director. • Phil Farinacci, Director of Business Development and Administration. • Ignacio Garcia, Director of Operations and Team Building Strategist.
Giving Back

Giving Back

Bread & Butter Hospitality strives to make a positive impact, both within and beyond the confines of our restaurants. We firmly believe that by extending our warm hospitality to the communities we serve, we not only enrich our own culture but also fortify our business. Bread & Butter Hospitality has long supported our community and neighbors through fundraising events and is the proud recipient of many awards and accolades for our distinct style of hospitality, including distinctions by The James Beard Foundation and The New York Wine & Food Festival. Bread & Butter Hospitality has made one of the largest donations to Staten Island University Hospital's Florina Cancer Center and have pledged to continue our support by increasing our commitment to $500,000.
Social & Corporate

Social & Corporate

Bread & Butter Hospitality presents an array of exclusive event experiences encompassing diverse cuisines, accommodating various size groups and versatile creative formats. We also offer off-premise catering. Book your special event with us today.
Join Us

Join Us

At Bread & Butter Hospitality, we value creativity, teamwork, and a strong dedication to excellence. We foster a supportive environment that encourages growth and provides opportunities for professional development. Join our team today!

How It All Began

  • 2014 October

    2014 October

    The Stone House

    Peter Botros opened The Stone House at Clove Lakes in 2014 at the age of 28. The historic Stone House at Clove Lakes is a charming cottage with stunning lakefront and woodland views.

  • 2016 February

    2016 February

    The Chef's Loft

    Peter Botros opens a Restaurant within a Restaurant at the Stone House at Clove Lakes. Guests ascend a spiral staircase to the loft for an intimate 5 course wine paired dinner prepared tableside.

  • 2017 November

    2017 November

    Violette's

    Peter Botros, along with Philip Farinacci and Marc Zurlo open Violette's Cellar as a tribute to their moms, Violette Botros, Sally Curtis and Andrea Zurlo who lost their brave fight with cancer.

  • 2019 January

    2019 January

    Sofia's Taqueria

    Sofia’s Taqueria, Staten Island’s first Taco & Tequila Bar was born on Bay Street.

  • 2020 January

    2020 January

    Tito Bandito's

    Our second location in the Catskills offers awesome mexican cusine. Tito Bandito's is a Taco and Tequila Bar located in Pine Hill NY.

  • 2020 June

    2020 June

    Rustic Pizza & Pasteria

    In June 2020, mid pandemic, Rustic Pizza & Pasteria, where everything is made from scratch, opened in Grant City. Rustic Pizza & Pasteria specializes in authentic Italian dishes, specialty pies, homem

  • 2020 September

    2020 September

    Sally's Southern & BBQ

    Paying special homage to Philip Farinacci's mother after she lost her brave fight with cancer, Sally's favorite recipes and even her handwriting are integrated into our Southern Comfort & BBQ menu.

  • 2021 September

    2021 September

    SOFIA'S TAQUERIA AMBOY LOCATION

    Sofia's Taqueria opened its second location serving the Eltingville community. Featuring an extra long bar, indoor & covered outdoor seating and private event space.

  • 2023 May

    2023 May

    SOFIA'S TAQUERIA FOREST LOCATION

    Sofia's Taqueria opens its third location with indoor and outdoor seating, an inside bar, a walk-up margarita window and private party space.

  • Sofia's Taqueria opens its third location with ind

    Sofia's Taqueria opens its third location with ind

    Sofias Old Bridge

    Sofia’s Group expands its horizons into Old Bridge NJ with its 4th Taqueria location serving up all of Sofia’s Favorites.

  • 2024 February

    2024 February

    Martin's kosher style deli

    Martin's Kosher Style Deli ghost kitchen operating out of Sally’s Southern & BBQ is launched, dedicated to delivering mouthwatering pastrami sandwiches and a variety of deli favorites. Enjoy authentic

  • 2024 June

    2024 June

    Blue Pearl

    Bread Butter Hospitality proudly opens a Modern American seafood and Vibe Dining experience and Event Venue set against the stunning backdrop of waterfront views and the iconic NYC skyline. Nestled wi

  • 2024 November

    2024 November

    Sofias toms river

    Bread Butter Hospitality is thrilled to announce the expansion of Sofia’s Taqueria to Toms River, New Jersey! This vibrant location features an exclusive “Tequila Room” perfect for private dining expe

  • 2024 November

    2024 November

    Rustic Expansion

    Rustic Pizza & Pasteria moves its location from 97 Lincoln Ave to 1789 Richmond Road offering a Full Bar - Dining Area - Happy Hour - Take out & Delivery

  • 2024 November

    2024 November

    Bread & Butter Burgers

    Bread and Butter Burgers launches a new ghost kitchen operating out of Sally’s Southern & BBQ ready to serve up a mouthwatering selection of burgers and more. With a focus on quality ingredients.

  • 2025 March

    2025 March

    Sofia's Taqueria Ledgewood NJ

    Monday March 31st marked the grand opening of our Sofia’s Taqueria Ledgewood Location! With a full bar and over 150 tequilas and mezcals, this location boasts all of our Sofia’s favorites.

  • 2025 July

    2025 July

    Pearl Lounge

    An Upscale Event Space/Cocktail lounge Concept by Blue Pearl, located at Urby Staten Island

  • 2025 August CAROLINES Tavern

    2025 August CAROLINES Tavern

    A fresh new American Tavern in Avenel, NJ. Offering happy hour, weekend brunch, and a full service bar.

  • 2025 November

    Carved

    Carved is a family-owned gourmet sandwich shop featuring an elevated twist on classic favorites, offering sandwiches, salads, soups, and more - all carefully crafted with fresh ingredients ensuring de

  • 2026 April

    2026 April

    Violettes Woodbridge

    Violette’s is Woodbridge NJ’s most anticipated new restaurant, bar, lounge, and event venue. Redefining “VIBE dining” with a bi level contemporary speakeasy experience.